23rd May 2012: GREXIT Could Be The Blueprint For A Complete Rewire Of The Euro
Quote of the Day:
A stitch in time saves nine
Old English Proverb
Macro Overview
The Cost Of Re-wiring A System
- When we were renovating our new house, we obtained many quotes for many things. One of which was the re-vamping of the electrical circuitry in the house. Much of the lighting was in need of repair and re-design and there was some seriously dodgy stuff going on – like spurring plug sockets off lighting rings etc!
- As it turned out, we needed to lift 80% of the floorboards in the house and the cost was, like, $9,000 for full works. The cost completely stripping out the entire aged (and slightly dodgy) circuitry was $10,000. On top of this we’d get a new distribution box with the latest RCDOs – a device which sorta combines the functionality of an RCD (surge protector) and a fuse (overload protector), which is pretty important when you have a family with small, inquisitive kids running around the house. But more importantly, because the electricians were doing all the work themselves for the entire house, they’d do an official test on the entire circuitry of the house and giving us a certificate to approve it under the (new) UK regulation by the necessary regulatory body.
- It was a no brainer – for the extra 1,000 bucks we just lifted every floorboard in the house and went for a full rewire, so our house is rigged to the highest standard and we knew everything about every circuit in the house (something which came in very useful when we installed solar panels!).
- What am I getting at here? Well, I’ve been thinking about Greece. I’d love to write about something else, like the US or China or even Japan. Yes! Japan! Nothing goes on there but I’m so tired of talking about Europe I’d rather write about paint drying. But, alas, we must, so Greece… where was I?
A Greek Holiday
- Ah yes… Today the finance minister of Luxembourgwas on Bloomberg TV talking very openly about a Greek exit – and very objectively assessing the risks of a bailout rejection by voters. Former Greek Prime Minister Lucas Papademos (remember him?) said that a Greek exit cannot be excluded, even El Erian says that at Greek exit is not possible but “probable”. Yesterday I commented on Pettis’ nonchalant attitude to (in his opinion) the almost inevitable crumbling of the Eurozone – I even hinted at some discussion on possible end-games for the Euro. Let’s start with a scenario I’ve been dreaming up… so here we go…
- Firstly, there is no mechanism for any member state to exit the Euro. As a portfolio manager I’m simply aghast that such a massively risky and complicated challenge was undertaken with no exit strategies of any sort. Still, moving on… no exit strategy and it seems that most of the administrative tasks of engineering an exit are feasible in theory with a bit of creativity and a lot of intestinal fortitude with one exception: the nightmare of achieving the redenomination of all the securities and instruments which reside on the balance sheets of many, many institutions including the banks and even on the balance sheets of individual people!
- But this is not out of the realm of European politicians. The European Council are bad at many things, but bureaucracy and legislation is actually something they are actually quite adept at when they need to be. Remember, Merkel’s grand Treaty Change happened pretty much exactly as I was writing about months before it occurred, but, for such an iconic piece of legislation, it was drafted pretty quickly – it just took them ages to come round to my ways, heheh!
- I think it is possible for the European elite (God bless their souls) to come up with a pretty comprehensive plan which would allow the Greeks to “take a sabbatical” from the Euro or a holiday from their austere oppressors in Northern Europe! This could be achieved while simultaneously predetermining certain conditions for Greek re-entry into the Eurozone orbit. Let’s face it, Europe managed to achieve something much more challenging than this, with 17, seemingly randomly independent economies – I think they can take care of one – even if it feels like a step backwards, psychologically.
Re-wiring The Euro
- But here’s the thing. The markets will react with some severity to a GREXIT and the European politicians, if they’ve learnt anything over the last 4 years (ahem!) need to prepare for this and be prepared to be politically pro-active.
- No sooner than the minute the first Drachma hits the street the market will turn it’ attention to Ireland, Portugal [insert for favourite candidate here]. It may be wise for European politicians to prepare to use Greece as a blueprint for a complete overhaul of the entire Euro model. After all Greek debt has its tentacles in every single banking system of very single European state. The GREXIT will blaze a trail for the rest of Europe as most of the legislative, legal, administrative, political and (importantly) psychological heavy-lifting would have already been achieved with the Greek proto-type model.
- I do not believe that the European public (never mind the politicians) would be willing to throw away half a century of political accomplishment and vote for a complete disintegration of the Euro – where a large number of countries revert back to their national currencies/monetary governance indefinitely. However, GREXIT would give the European Council a blueprint and a testing ground for a complete “re-wire” of the Eurozone monetary circuit.
- Re-wire the system – what does this mean? Well, for example (and let’s just fire any absurd notion that comes to mind here)… a complete dissection of the Euro into two currencies (a strong, Northern, austere currency and a weak, Southern, profligate currency) or perhaps a Euro-core with a number of satellite Euro-derivatives (i.e. hard-coding a pan-Eurozone exit strategy). This is not completely impractical, given the circumstances. Afterall… figuratively speaking, by slogging through GREXIT have already lifted up 80% of the floorboards so they might as well re-wire the whole house – a stitch in time saves nine.
Market Overview
It’s A Cyclical Old Game
- Well, after Nat Gas and Volatility surged I’ve had to think of something else to talk about (until they correct a little again). I’ve been thinking of the Euro discussion we’ve been having (well, OK, I’ve been having with myself, then). Whatever happens, the future of the Euro is uncertain. The probability of the composition of the Euro changing (i.e. one of more member leaving or a complete overhaul of the currency) is not significant.
- It’s not easy to think about how to invest in this circumstance. For example, shorting the Euro at this level could prove to be very painful even if the Eurozone were to split or disintegrate, the basis of that trade would end up being the sum of those parts which (the market may anticipate to be) worth more than the whole (Euro) in the first place.
- One thing I think we can be quite optimistic about is the potential for Euro volatility. I’m not talking so much about buying Euro volatility per se (although I think the long-dated Euro straddle trade is still relevant and would have made you a decent clip so far), but rather volatility in the companies with cost structures in Northern and Southern Eurozone (but not companies which have pan-European operations and are therefore more hedged to any form of Euro disintegration).
- I think initially a split of any form will see the peripheral currency fall very sharply while the core currency will rise (to an extent dependent on how many weak currency nations are still members).
- If we imagine, for a minute a Northern Germanic Euro and a Southern Mediterranean Euro, it’s quite clear that the Northern Euro will get suddenly stronger and the Southern Euro will weaken significantly. But it’s a cyclical old game, dear reader – this would be a great time to sell the spread between the two… I know I’m getting ahead of myself here but let’s remember… Germany has never had to export products to a European customer with a devalued currency, nor has it ever had to compete with Europeans companies with a devalued cost structure. There is a point at which Eurozone peripherals would (and should) be able to claw back competitiveness… I suppose that’s the whole point really…
- The rest of the market… well, look on the bright side… at least Facebook opened UP.
- Chart of the Day – The Euro (of course) but I also have to throw in the British 5 year interest rate as indicated by GBP swaps. That’s a 20 year chart… yep, we’re at a 20 year low… in fact probably an all time historic low… people are buying government bonds that promise to yield only 1.4% in a country with a debt to GDP closing pretty quickly in on 100%, where inflation is 3% and the central bank is hell bent of printing the currency (the denomination of those very same bonds) into oblivion… hmmm… that should give you an idea about risk appetite!
Chart of the Day
Events
Macro Events:
Update:
- Malaysian GDP pretty much in line at 4.7% YoY
Alerts:
- Germany GDP
- Mexico GDP
- UK GDP
Corporate Events:
Results:
- Costco [COST], Royal Bank of Cananda [RY CN], SAB Miller [SAB LN],
Dividends:
- Johnson & Johnson [JNJ], SAP [SAP GR],
Reading, Links:
Nothing Significant





























