4th October 2011: Maximus – The Great European Crisis That Simply Won’t Die
Quote of the Day:
… you simply won’t … DIE [click here]
Commodus to Maximus (Film: Gladiator)
Macro Overview
- Interesting in films like Gladiator and Spartacus renegades at the periphery of this diverse continent were centralized to the political heart of the superpower. And yet, while seemingly politically powerless, they managed to infiltrate the order to bring the entire empire to its knees. Each year I’m astounded by our modern day senate in Brussels… with their procrastination and deliberation they succeed only to transform relatively powerlessly enslaved outlaws into a gladiatorial behemoths. We should not be surprised: snatching poverty from the jaws of prosperity is something politicians have got incredibly adept at. But that’s enough of films.
- So, Europe, how are those “let’s buy-some-time policies” working out for you? I see German CDS now at the highest level since … ermmm… actually since my records begin. But let’s put it this way 5 year Dollar German CDS is now trading 30% wider than the wides during the 2008/9 crisis. The VDAX volatility level surged to a nauseating 2 year high. See the Charts of the Day.
- As usual the focus is on The Great The European Crisis that simply will not die and the global economic drag associated with it. Goldman downgraded the economic outlook for the entire region, predicting a recession in Germany and France (albeit mild) and a severe recession at the periphery. They also put a nail in the Euro/USD coffin. That sounds about right, the only beef I have with it was their 1% target for UK growth… I’d put it closer to zero.
- A good little article by the sophistocrats at Stratfor (European Crisis: Precise Solutions in an Imprecise Reality | STRATFOR) tries to summarize the problem succinctly:
…the complexity of the European situation is less driven by the complexity of the economics than by the complexity of the politics.
— — —
The political and geopolitical problem is simply this: Germany is unique in Europe in terms of both size and values. It tried to create a free trade zone based on German values allied with France that looked at the world in a much more complex way. The crisis we are seeing, which Germany is trying to solve with extraordinary complexity and precision, rests on a highly unstable base. First, the European banking system, like the American banking system, does not understand its status. Second, the entire mathematics of national statistics is inherently imprecise. Third, the peripheral countries of the European Union have economies that cannot be measured at all because their informal economies are massive. The fundamental principles and self-conception of Germany and Central Europe diverge massively. The elites of these countries might like to think of themselves as Europeans first — by the German definition — but the publics know they are not, and they don’t want to be.
- “Bernanke to take further action to aid growth” – reads Bloomberg headline in a seemingly eureka moment. Boost growth! Why didn’t we think of that before? The reality of course, is exactly what Bernanke himself said, it’s no longer obvious that the upside to additional monetary stimulus exceeds the downside. But as Axel Merk points out in his latest piece, the stars are aligning for Bernanke’s QE3. As his graph, points out – operation twist has been going on for a long time now, well before the “twist announcement”.
- Bernanke’s in a tough situation. He must convince us that he has our best interests at heart while inflating our savings away like a maniac. Amusingly, Merk takes a sarcastic swipe at the Princeton Professor’s salesmanship:
It looks like Bernanke at least wants to maintain the appearance of keeping long-term inflation expectations low. Earlier this year, Bernanke complained a few times that the risk-reward ratio of another round of easing is not all that clear. Well, how about making it clearer, by:
- First crushing the short end of the yield curve by committing to keep interest rates low until the middle of 2013.
- Then lower long-term interest rates by initiating “Operation Twist”, the selling of short-term securities by the Fed in the billions, then reinvesting the proceeds in long-term securities.
- From another angle, Bill Gross points out other ineffective realities of policy-makers in this piece (Six Packin’).
Yet to return to my initial criticism of cyclically finance-based as opposed to structural policy solutions, almost all remedies proposed by global authorities to date have approached the problem from the standpoint of favoring capital as opposed to labor. If the banks could just be stabilized, if the “markets” could just be elevated back in the direction of peak 401(k) levels, if interest rates could just be lower so that borrowers would inevitably take the bait, then labor – job creation – would inevitably follow. It has not. The explanation for why not must at least include the rationale that Wall Street and Main Street are symbiotically connected and if one benefits at theexpense of the other, then both ultimately can falter.
- In a way I hope Bernanke announces “QE to infinity” it’ll do wonders for my stock investments. But of course, this will only exacerbate China’s growth recession/inflation problem (soon to be compounded by more anti-China rhetoric in America) which is not good for anybody – least of all investors in Asia, who will be yet more susceptible to fat tail risk. Let’s face it, if the answer to all our problems was purely in the one-trick-pony of a money-printing Fed we would have been high and dry and sipping Pina Coladas a long time ago.
Market Overview
- Missed by most mainstream newspapers the Hong Kong Standard picked up that the notion of a short-sell ban in Hong Kong was indeed on the table. Short-sell bans worked well for European banks didn’t it? But we need to be very wary, short positions are at a record high indicating that the short side may be more concentrated than we think and therefore highly susceptible to aggressive and protracted short-covering rallies.
- Speaking of which, as the market weighed up the consequences of a Greek default it also came to the conclusion that Dexia is basically screwed. Interesting that this (relatively small bank) had €3.4 billion exposure to Greece (the largest of any major European bank) and yet was given a bill of good health by those nonsensical European banking stress tests. As I wrote back in June in my piece, The Art of Political Deception, Part 1 – Evolution of the European Greek Debt Crisis:
…banking capital requirements and Basel III aside, let us not forget that is it was the Committee of European Banking Supervisors (CEBS – or Committee for the Effluence of utter Bullsh#t, if you prefer) who effectively told us that the banking system was hunky dory. They’d looked at the contagion effects, did a sophisticated “stress-test” (that was far more stringent than the American one, apparently) and said it was all good, saving a small handful of small Spanish regional banks. The CEBS then gave themselves a little pat on the back and gave the European banks a little pat on the bum and said: “there, there… run along now, you cheeky monkeys!” Hmmm… that was a bit of a misrepresentation then – again, the credibility question is raised. As Stephen Pope put it at the time: ”I see nothing stressful about this test. It’s like sending the banks away for a weekend of R&R,” – and so it proved to be. I didn’t delve into the detail, but we all knew that the stress tests on both sides of the Atlantic were just another comical act in a political pantomime. We are now seeing the downside of such misrepresentation.
- Well anyway, consequences of pathetically weak management are that the Dexia receives the honorary title of being in need of a bail out for a second time. If you’re a bank CEO when political leaders “pledge support” for your bank it can only mean one thing: it’s time to pack your bags.
- When the S&P traded down 2% right from the outset I feared the worst for our resistance level, but I was pleasantly surprised by how much equities held up in the end due mainly to Bernanke’s precisely timed hint at further “stimulus”. Personally, I think it may have worked in the short term, I don’t think there is a big enough sell off through the 1100 level on the S&P to spark a capitulation… as far as resistance is concerned this is a “hold” and we could rally from here into the weekend. It all depends on this ISM number tomorrow and the subsequent data thereafter.
Chart of the Day
Events
Macro Events:
Update:
- Chinese PMI Services actually came out pretty good at over 59.3 (particularly encouraging that it was the service industry putting out) – a glimmer of hope indeed.
Alerts:
- US ISM Non-Manufacturing
- UKGDP Q2 Confirmation
- Taiwan CPI
- Philippines CPI
Corporate Events:
Results:
- CostCo [COST]
Dividends:
- American Express [AXP], AT&T [T],
Reading, Links:
EU Behemoth:




































